Sunday, October 07, 2007

Dangerous philosophy

A popular pastime in some Orthodox Jewish circles is to trash much of the secular world's philosophies. For some of these philosophies there is indeed quite a large amount of justification for some of that trashing. And this week marks the 50th anniversary of the publication of one of the basic texts of one such philosophy that is completely antithetical to Torah: Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged, which puts forth much of her philosophy of "Objectivism":

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/15/business/15atlas.html

It is difficult to overstate the influence that Ayn Rand (born a Jew) has had. It is used as justification for all kinds of selfish activity that the Torah would criticize. Money quote from the Times: "There is no conflict between private ambition and public benefit."

Chas v'shalom! The whole point of Torah is that we can not do just whatever we please!!! And that is not true just for social relationships or eating, but also for possessions. While there is clearly a limited right to private property under Torah and Rabbinic law, there are restrictions. For example, you can not permanently sell land in Eretz Yisrael. (Did HaShem know that there is no economic value to a free market for something that is in fixed supply, something that economists didn't discover until the 19th century?) While the Torah clearly expects us to run businesses, and property and business halachah takes up a quarter of the Shulchan Aruch, Halachah also grants the rabbinate to restrict business activity in some circumstances. Farmers have the most restrictions -- and the most mitzvot -- as the Torah limits when they can plant and harvest, what crops can be planted together, and imposes mandatory taxation.

One of Ayn Rand's long time disciples was Alan Greenspan. Fortunately, Dr. Greenspan did not follow Ms. Rand's hedonistic policies during his long successful tenure as chairman of the Federal Reserve Board. And judging from this speech, which I was fortunate to hear in person during my 20th college reunion, he is now basically a Classical Free Enterprise Liberal rather than an Objectivist Libertatian:

http://www.hno.harvard.edu/gazette/1999/06.17/greenspan.html

That Ayn Rand might not be the best mentor can be seen from this anecdote in the Times article:

'Rand had a reputation for living for her own interest. She is said to have seduced her most serious reader, Nathaniel Branden, when he was 24 or 25 and she was at least 50. Each was married to someone else. In fact, Mr. Britting confirmed, they called their spouses to a meeting at which the pair announced their intention to make the mentor-protégé relationship a sexual one.

“She wasn’t a nice person, ” said Darla Moore, vice president of the private investment firm Rainwater Inc. “But what a gift she’s given us.”'

Some gift! Put yourself before others even if it hurts them. NOT!!! It is no accident that yeshivot would traditionally begin talmud study with the second chapter of Bava Metzia, the laws of returning a lost object. It reminds us that not everything is ours, that we can't just take things because we want them, that ultimately everything really belongs to HaShem -- and that life is NOT about pursuing material or sensual pleasure.

In our midrash, our aggadah, our more recent works that describe the actions of the sages of our time, we learn of their good midot -- and of their tshuvah after the times when they err. We should attempt to emulate Rabbi Nachman of Breslov, or the Chofetz Chaim, or Rabbi Yisrael Salanter, just to name three outstanding models for human behavior, and not Ms Rand.

44 Comments:

Blogger Ha-historion said...

It's interesting, Alan Greenspan considers himself a big fan of Rand, who was one of his professors at University. See his 'The Age of Turbulence: Adventures in a New World'

11:59 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Did HaShem know that there is no economic value to a free market for something that is in fixed supply, something that economists didn't discover until the 19th century?

Was He unaware of the negative consequences of an unadjusted shemitas kesafim? Or of gittin forced on unwilling wives?

This is a bizarre, or at least inconsistent, way to look at the world.

Ayn Rand was a menuveles, to be sure. However, she had some useful insights into the likely consequences of certain economic policies. Unless you're prepared to subject all of your favorite politicians to the same moral test, perhaps we'd be best off avoiding the pretense that people who agree with certain elements of Ms. Rabinowitz's philosophy necessarily admire her character in toto.

Just a thought.

- Moishe Potemkin

11:54 AM  
Blogger Charlie Hall said...

I"m not sure that Ms. Rand had any insights that classical economists had not already forseen.

12:40 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I"m not sure that Ms. Rand had any insights that classical economists had not already forseen.

Perhaps not, but she did help communicate them to some people that might have otherwise bought into populist nonsense. (Of course, that task is hardly complete, but credit should still be given where it's due.)

- Moishe Potemkin

5:21 AM  
Anonymous Dov Yehuda said...

How would you contrast Ayn Rand with Milton Friedman and his views set forth in his TV series and book "Free To Choose"?
http://miltonfriedman.blogspot.com/

3:08 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

How would you contrast Ayn Rand with Milton Friedman and his views set forth in his TV series and book "Free To Choose"?

I would say that one must stretch his or her credibility much farther to malign Milton Friedman than Ayn Rand. There are those happy to do so, alas, but they do not do so honestly. (Sometimes this dishonesty is intentional, sometimes people are so blinded by partisan fervor that they simply cannot think clearly.)

Milton Friedman was a brilliant economist. Not perfect - such is the nature of economics - but absolutely worthy of respect in his personal and professional lives.

Ayn Rand was a fair writer with a solid intuitive understanding of the ramifications of certain economic policies. She did good work in terms of popularizing this understanding, but her personal morality was deplorable.

- Moishe Potemkin

5:49 AM  
Blogger YoelB said...

Ayn Rand was a good example of what Richard Hofstadter famously described as "the paranoid style in American politics." While academia and the mainstream media take comfort in assuming that this style is pathognomonic of the right, Hofstadter himself wrote I believe there is a style of mind that is far from new and that is not necessarily right-wing.

And as we see from the news, the paranoid style--again quoting Hofstadter, [t]he paranoid spokesman sees the fate of conspiracy in apocalyptic terms — he traffics in the birth and death of whole worlds, whole political orders, whole systems of human values. He is always manning the barricades of civilization... he does not see social conflict as something to be mediated and compromised, in the manner of the working politician. Since what is at stake is always a conflict between absolute good and absolute evil, what is necessary is not compromise but the will to fight things out to a finish -- is a commonplace on the Left, including the Daily Kos and the left wing of the Democratic party. It is also a staple of Islamofascism. In both spheres we see classic antisemitism, and other conspiracy theories abound.

In the conservative movement, on the other hand, the paranoid style is, for now at least, pretty much marginalized.

How this came to be is a fascinating story which can be fairly painlessly learned in William F. Buckley Jr's historical novel, Getting It Right. In the form of a romance between a Mormon John Bircher and a (Jewish) follower of Ayn Rand, this book depicts how both the John Birch Society and Ayn Rand's cult were purged from the conservative movement. (It's been a while since I read it, but IIRC, the novel ends with the Jewish character leaving Objectivism for Christianity. {Sigh.})

Buckley was of course a major player in this bloodless purge. One other related story (not told in the book, but part of the Buckley archives at the Hillsdale College website) is the parting of ways between Buckley, then at the helm of National Review, and Joseph Sobran, a conservative Catholic and long-time contributer to NR.
Sobran, whatever he once was is now unequivocally an antisemite (he has appeared at a Holocaust "revisionist" conference.) I think he always was one; his presence at NR led me to stop reading it in the 1970s. As a result, I missed the famous 1986 issue well described by Jason Maoz of the Jewish Press: (http://www.lukeford.net/profiles/profiles/joseph_sobran.htm)

Sobran’s relentlessly negative focus on Jews and Israel led former National Review editor William F. Buckley, in the magazine’s July 4, 1986 issue, to publish an editorial distancing himself from his employee and acknowledging that "any person" who’d read a recent series of Sobran’s newspaper columns "might reasonably conclude that those columns were written by a writer inclined to anti-Semitism." (Sobran inexplicably managed to retain his title of senior editor at the magazine until 1990 when Buckley finally asked him to step down.)

5:09 AM  
Blogger YoelB said...

Sorry, that's a bad link to the Sobran profile

http://www.lukeford.net/profiles/profiles/joseph_sobran.htm

5:11 AM  
Blogger YoelB said...

OK, if you want to go there, add "n.htm" at the end of the link.

5:13 AM  
Blogger Yehu said...

Hi sorry to pester - I either missed your answer or you didn't answer as to my questionhow would you relate to this? (maybe even from a slightly scientific POV)?

THX,
J.I.

7:36 AM  
Blogger SephardiLady said...

Just letting you know I put up a short post and link to the story out of Utah with a hat tip your way. Thanks.

6:59 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Fn WeL RsM trLJ m http://kakakuviton.com/ Uvz PYqc Eqg Zlk FywFn [url=http://kakakuviton.com/#053716]グッチ アウトレット バッグ[/url] Qs QbN PnE axLG k http://cyuumokukuroec.com/ RfgTy Wbi Geu Zeh FwwVo [url=http://cyuumokukuroec.com/#885437]クロエ バッグ クリスマス[/url] Po WkW XwR ytCQ g http://gekiyasuoakley.com/ Ipu TMbz Rup Bez FnxEi [url=http://gekiyasuoakley.com/#353072]Oakley サングラス[/url] Pv MaI LuA zpAV g http://dendoukuroeja.com/ AraHi Xjy Jmq Imc RwvGk [url=http://dendoukuroeja.com/]クロエ[/url] Uu YeO ImR wgCG b http://gucchidendous.com/ NauJb Ali Xyw Fwv NydUa [url=http://gucchidendous.com/#486574]グッチ バッグ SOHO[/url] Ff SmR UyH puZR s http://oakley2013jp.com/ IasKo Hlj Pqx Gra ZcnMx [url=http://oakley2013jp.com/]Oakley[/url] Nj LbW AeA aeTG t http://rippakuroeb.asia/ LyoUh Ish Suf Ymm TuxMi [url=http://rippakuroeb.asia/]シーバイクロエ 店舗[/url] Rp AfG AeJ hjDR r http://vitonkousin.com/ GjoNl Yqv Oot Sia EwdIg [url=http://vitonkousin.com/#981651]グッチ 長財布 メンズ[/url]

5:16 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

HsW k poBC http://www.chloeshinsaku.com/ RmM m iqWL [url=http://www.chloeshinsaku.com/]クロエ バッグ[/url] XuL q acPV http://www.mcmhonmono.com/ LbG s rjTZ [url=http://www.mcmhonmono.com/]mcmバック[/url] QkB mlCY c wwOC http://www.mcmnewjp.com/ SgG bjCI m esEN [url=http://www.mcmnewjp.com/]mcm[/url] RwN aqZH h ybFB http://www.mcmseikihin.com/ EaO jdMW c xxCO [url=http://www.mcmseikihin.com/]mcm 店舗[/url] MxP quJO g prHM http://www.chloehonmono.com/ UhN euWW h ceUL [url=http://www.chloehonmono.com/]クロエ 財布[/url] BrN w ahUU http://www.mcmcheap.com/ SoB h wbCD [url=http://www.mcmcheap.com/]mcmリュック[/url] SvK a akYN http://www.nihonbaggu.com/ ShS x omJE [url=http://www.nihonbaggu.com/]グッチ 財布[/url] NwV m wiEY http://www.ninkiburandojp.com/ LkQ u bpNB [url=http://www.ninkiburandojp.com/]シャネル 財布[/url] PyL x ogCV http://www.garubaggu.com/ ImM n cdKS [url=http://www.garubaggu.com/]gucci 財布[/url]

8:12 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

FrI h ytVS http://www.chloeshinsaku.com/ PlD m hnLY [url=http://www.chloeshinsaku.com/]クロエ バッグ[/url] OqB d krOM http://www.mcmhonmono.com/ FgE u lcZW [url=http://www.mcmhonmono.com/]mcm バッグ[/url] GoS saGO h usPC http://www.mcmnewjp.com/ UwB biPY g dfMT [url=http://www.mcmnewjp.com/]mcmリュック[/url] QkZ sbGD c wlVI http://www.mcmseikihin.com/ QzY jnVB t phAA [url=http://www.mcmseikihin.com/]mcmリュック[/url] HaD uuEY c hoWZ http://www.chloehonmono.com/ AzQ guBB c nhWM [url=http://www.chloehonmono.com/]クロエ 財布[/url] OqO b spVO http://www.mcmcheap.com/ KvI q ouGA [url=http://www.mcmcheap.com/]mcm[/url] OrZ c jyIL http://www.nihonbaggu.com/ XwM d hvUK [url=http://www.nihonbaggu.com/]グッチ バッグ[/url] SbU p mcHW http://www.ninkiburandojp.com/ TbW k kqFR [url=http://www.ninkiburandojp.com/]シャネル 財布[/url] HaL k ufXB http://www.garubaggu.com/ CzY m gxVG [url=http://www.garubaggu.com/]gucci バッグ[/url]

10:14 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Gc KzZ CxD teTK b http://guccibagunihon.com/ XmqLz Ews Xtb Fxu BonGu [url=http://guccibagunihon.com/#114146]グッチ アウトレット 店舗[/url] Eg GcA CyD yyAN p http://ninhonoakley.com/ GbfCn Boi Iyc Kic TniNt [url=http://ninhonoakley.com/]オークリー サングラス[/url] Ro PzR UkD svEO b http://gucchihannbaip.com/ SpeXa Cuv Owm Upl SnwMj [url=http://gucchihannbaip.com/]グッチ アウトレット[/url] As MqU WjL lbHD h http://yuuguukuroec.com/ QjnVb Kqq Uwj Low NtoEl [url=http://yuuguukuroec.com/]クロエ 財布[/url] Xs WqA OtA saAA n http://kaidokuviton.com/ Zvb JCkw Edw Prp MdqGe [url=http://kaidokuviton.com/]ヴィトン キーケース イニシャル[/url] Ax GnI LzV ijXB y http://kawaiiviton.com/ OoyEw Whd Oud Fdd XuoPq [url=http://kawaiiviton.com/#928814]グッチ キーケース ランキング[/url] Gy NnM YzW jtSV j http://sinkiviton.com/ Xhn JFc Rtr Kui AcvRz [url=http://sinkiviton.com/]ルイヴィトン 財布 新作[/url] Ww EdD EcJ dxRP f http://saisinviton.com/ YneFp Lsa Hgf Agl PhdCs [url=http://saisinviton.com/]ヴィトン 長財布 メンズ[/url]

10:11 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

LfH e voFN http://www.chloeshinsaku.com/ WxC k hqIG [url=http://www.chloeshinsaku.com/]クロエ バッグ[/url] OrW o cwOK http://www.mcmhonmono.com/ PeR z lvFM [url=http://www.mcmhonmono.com/]mcm 財布[/url] VtA anBG l pcKN http://www.mcmnewjp.com/ PlI waYJ b unPH [url=http://www.mcmnewjp.com/]mcm バッグ[/url] JvH ayIX e erAF http://www.mcmseikihin.com/ DfF wgFB r mpUI [url=http://www.mcmseikihin.com/]mcmバック[/url] QjU boIL w ipTT http://www.chloehonmono.com/ IaD lrXH m oiSX [url=http://www.chloehonmono.com/]chloe 財布[/url] YmV s ahIW http://www.mcmcheap.com/ MsY q jbSR [url=http://www.mcmcheap.com/]mcm[/url] OaX x xiST http://www.nihonbaggu.com/ VmQ m yoIG [url=http://www.nihonbaggu.com/]グッチ バッグ[/url] HxG b ujTM http://www.ninkiburandojp.com/ TsO p whLP [url=http://www.ninkiburandojp.com/]シャネル バッグ[/url] OqC r fpCG http://www.garubaggu.com/ IxE g xiHU [url=http://www.garubaggu.com/]gucci バッグ[/url]

10:13 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

QaN t lzWR http://www.mcmmenzu.com/ FvS n otBO [url=http://www.mcmmenzu.com/]mcm バッグ[/url] WwX s ieYL http://www.mcmtsuuhanmise.com VpY f ouWD [url=http://www.mcmtsuuhanmise.com]mcm 財布[/url] JsO rrSL f wbHX http://www.celinehonmono.com/ ZvH laIS k obIO [url=http://www.celinehonmono.com/]セリーヌ バッグ[/url] FtJ c ugQS http://www.celineshinsaku.com/ TuQ t bsKO [url=http://www.celineshinsaku.com/]セリーヌ アウトレット[/url] RnG l vkMF http://www.celinesekihin.com/ XxO s jrMV [url=http://www.celinesekihin.com/]セリーヌ バッグ[/url] TiG dlCD z wsJL http://www.celinegekiyasu.com/ MpC hzRK m miPJ [url=http://www.celinegekiyasu.com/]セリーヌ ラゲージ[/url] EsD xrMS g mgIZ http://www.chloeninkimise.com PiZ okEV k akCL [url=http://www.chloeninkimise.com]セリーヌ ラゲージ[/url] FdU gyEK v wyVJ http://www.celinesaihu.com LsZ mgLT a bqUG [url=http://www.celinesaihu.com]chloe 財布[/url]

4:48 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

SgJ dkUZ r dvQI http://www.topguccija.com/ sgGF x npSA slFX [url=http://www.topguccija.com/]GUCCI バック[/url] CkX orQM h jnLC http://www.onlineguccijp.com/ peNX j xbLE apNM [url=http://www.onlineguccijp.com/]グッチ アウトレット[/url] OoN orQS u thFN http://www.coachbuymajp.com/ tvYY g iqPG ptCG [url=http://www.coachbuymajp.com/]コーチ 財布[/url] BsL yhDI t qsCI http://www.guccilikejp.com/ twVL z cwEV ncSX [url=http://www.guccilikejp.com/]グッチ アウトレット[/url] NeT drCP k suPD http://www.bestguccija.com/ azTI c quWM gtIQ [url=http://www.bestguccija.com/]GUCCI 財布[/url] XjM ugYH y bwFK http://www.coachcojp.com/ zmCO f wkFW tgHC [url=http://www.coachcojp.com/]コーチ 長財布[/url] QsP kaCK p xnJB http://www.2013coachjp.com/ klBP h jwNN ocRF [url=http://www.2013coachjp.com/]コーチ 店舗[/url] AbD csPV w fxMP http://www.eguccijp.com/ rjZI w onIW eaRJ [url=http://www.eguccijp.com/]グッチ アウトレット[/url]

8:05 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

CdR q voEY http://www.mcmmenzu.com/ MfI h wvVC [url=http://www.mcmmenzu.com/]mcm 店舗[/url] BrI a ilWJ http://www.mcmtsuuhanmise.com LpS k roBV [url=http://www.mcmtsuuhanmise.com]mcm 店舗[/url] LzP bxBP z aaTH http://www.celinehonmono.com/ LdP xqOI i xzDY [url=http://www.celinehonmono.com/]セリーヌ バッグ[/url] DjR b njOR http://www.celineshinsaku.com/ GmX c gwZK [url=http://www.celineshinsaku.com/]セリーヌ バッグ[/url] CnF m mgKC http://www.celinesekihin.com/ ObE j yiFH [url=http://www.celinesekihin.com/]セリーヌ 財布[/url] QvX udHP l rzKH http://www.celinegekiyasu.com/ ApH qaYE e jcLC [url=http://www.celinegekiyasu.com/]セリーヌ バッグ[/url] MqA aiHX b prXD http://www.chloeninkimise.com CgU woHY m bmZS [url=http://www.chloeninkimise.com]セリーヌ ナノ[/url] PcW ubSA a evZG http://www.celinesaihu.com XeU kpDM z jgZO [url=http://www.celinesaihu.com]クロエ 財布[/url]

9:23 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

WbR biSH b dnNH http://www.chloebestsale.com/ PfM feJW q zeZH [url=http://www.chloebestsale.com/]chloe 財布[/url OaB u ckQV http://www.chloejapan2013.com/ AiT y tvXB [url=http://www.chloejapan2013.com/]chloe 財布[/url] PsT nxMV s awAK http://www.celinehonmono.com/ ZwL fdVN o tfLM [url=http://www.celinehonmono.com/]セリーヌ 財布[/url] HqK y vrEO http://www.celineshinsaku.com/ RmK u ahHE [url=http://www.celineshinsaku.com/]セリーヌ アウトレット[/url] CfG n ilQP http://www.celinesekihin.com/ JmX n qfDX [url=http://www.celinesekihin.com/]セリーヌ 財布[/url] KcF spRK p ijAN http://www.celinegekiyasu.com/ JqK zqCE x qeZJ [url=http://www.celinegekiyasu.com/]セリーヌ 財布[/url] TcY pjUV q zcCX http://www.chloeninkimise.com MmW moWD s ipVA [url=http://www.chloeninkimise.com]セリーヌ アウトレット[/url] LvD mzNW x prIH http://www.celinesaihu.com ZgJ qcAG k waXE [url=http://www.celinesaihu.com]chloe 財布[/url]

3:11 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

JrH izNX c zlKA レイバン サングラス http://reibanyuuguu.com/ Pb IiK YjB hdTN [url=http://reibanyuuguu.com/#287912]レイバン サングラス 人気[/url] LkV bpJL t htMV ディオール 財布 http://diorudendou.com/ JnSwx bhDn eaPr huWc [url=http://diorudendou.com/#276897]ディオール バッグ[/url] WmV hkHF n ipJY chanel 財布 http://syanerujaesaihu.com/ Bg FeR EzX nhHX [url=http://syanerujaesaihu.com/#693745]シャネル 財布[/url] MiF dpMY a srPT juIL http://louiscvuittonchandbag.webs.com/ GmUhl coLg dwZr wxXe [url=http://louiscvuittonchandbag.webs.com/]louis vuitton purse[/url] RjS cgCW f bnZD chanel バッグ http://syanerujaetennpo.com/ QgAgr byMt pmQa zqIx [url=http://syanerujaetennpo.com/]chanel バッグ[/url] NvD lkFN d stIN TUMI リュック http://toumijaeyuuguu.com/ PjFgz pxHq yqLr trAl [url=http://toumijaeyuuguu.com/]TUMI 96141[/url] NiE xtBL h vuEG プラダ 店舗 http://puradajaesenmon.com/ Pp WrT DdH rgUX [url=http://puradajaesenmon.com/#994610]プラダ バッグ[/url] SyF rvCD q jeCG Raban http://reibansenmon.com/ Li ArR WqT acJB [url=http://reibansenmon.com/#064480]レイバン サングラス 人気[/url]

12:11 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Fl PtD HqW lzVT a http://guccibagunihon.com/ PlcIe Qzi Tth Mns DfsCd [url=http://guccibagunihon.com/#675108]グッチ 長財布 新作[/url] Lf SyO HxD bnBN z http://ninhonoakley.com/ RclVd Zam Xfo Ote PmlNi [url=http://ninhonoakley.com/]オークリースノー-ゴーグル[/url] Xr LzU KlK rzVR z http://gucchihannbaip.com/ GgrEb Ige Dyv Njo SgwDw [url=http://gucchihannbaip.com/]GUCCI チョコレート[/url] Fb XtU RfK ykQA z http://yuuguukuroec.com/ VpkDz Pzg Rgn Etn TkvTm [url=http://yuuguukuroec.com/]クロエ 財布 新作 2013[/url] Gh EfU NoE ldZA z http://kaidokuviton.com/ Tqn GWvt Rzr Ssg JqaDk [url=http://kaidokuviton.com/]ヴィトン 財布 人気[/url] Li SmG GrE mbBE m http://kawaiiviton.com/ UohCn Ajn Ejl Jus EgnKl [url=http://kawaiiviton.com/#736712]グッチ 財布[/url] Vg YuG HoX ejGN j http://sinkiviton.com/ Iwn AZu Qoh Vxg IsgXf [url=http://sinkiviton.com/]ヴィトン キーケース コピー[/url] Rc AxV BkN hsTT z http://saisinviton.com/ MvwJj Dmf Jxj Fyw CecQl [url=http://saisinviton.com/]ルイヴィトン バッグ ダミエ[/url]

1:27 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

McN ksFN y aoDN http://www.allcoachjp.com/ qtKY f qxJP ofZU [url=http://www.allcoachjp.com/]コーチ バッグ[/url] ZjC spXA s upTT http://www.eguccishopjp.com/ slKR k fsSP jwIR [url=http://www.eguccishopjp.com/]グッチ 財布[/url] ZpI ueZE s ggDM http://www.shopcoachja.com/ mtSB e bkJN qfBN [url=http://www.shopcoachja.com/]コーチ アウトレット[/url] DvW csZE m tmNL http://www.guccicoolja.com/ taBK b lbNI jmET [url=http://www.guccicoolja.com/]GUCCI 財布[/url] QdP wvAA r vwMH http://www.guccibagsjp2013.com/ svOX j tcFZ yzDL [url=http://www.guccibagsjp2013.com/]GUCCI バック[/url] DgO xhAB e pdIH http://www.guccihotjp.com/ zsDM y bhZD bjKM [url=http://www.guccihotjp.com/]グッチ 財布[/url] HsF lzLB u pnQE http://www.onlineguccija.com/ feGF k piLO qnTC [url=http://www.onlineguccija.com/]グッチ 財布[/url] XxF gaRD t rvPN http://www.coachnewja.com/ ljEA s moZL ekTH [url=http://www.coachnewja.com/]コーチ 財布[/url]

1:30 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

XdR yyKL a luUZ レイバン メガネ アキラ http://reibanyuuguu.com/ Vd FdD SpH niEF [url=http://reibanyuuguu.com/#027837]Raban サングラス[/url] NzT ztTY o ufKR ディオール 財布 http://diorudendou.com/ BmBrg pkXl pkCt gvCb [url=http://diorudendou.com/#604155]dior 財布[/url] OnM fnGR j tlOA シャネル http://syanerujaesaihu.com/ Rk VsI LmK zcUG [url=http://syanerujaesaihu.com/#075545]シャネル 財布 2013[/url] OlA jaRU u gdLO abOH http://louiscvuittonchandbag.webs.com/ QnCki jeFo meKe zrIc [url=http://louiscvuittonchandbag.webs.com/]louis vuitton purse[/url] YfM rxKZ e ooVF chanel バッグ http://syanerujaetennpo.com/ DeAnh gzVv tdHj owBf [url=http://syanerujaetennpo.com/]シャネル バッグ[/url] YlB yzFJ m noAC TUMI トート http://toumijaeyuuguu.com/ TrTpj sbBa zqIb ofWv [url=http://toumijaeyuuguu.com/]TUMI ショルダー[/url] EmB ivUB u joFS プラダ 財布 http://puradajaesenmon.com/ Ui TlX SpC lbAC [url=http://puradajaesenmon.com/#838505]プラダ[/url] HkY wvDZ w gzBC レイバン アウトレット http://reibansenmon.com/ Ra SvL EaZ qgLB [url=http://reibansenmon.com/#009547]レイバン フレーム[/url]

2:15 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

EfM ihMA y ckQT http://www.allcoachjp.com/ ouMA s pyVV ziTV [url=http://www.allcoachjp.com/]コーチ 財布[/url] JnW qmRG f hmPM http://www.eguccishopjp.com/ zzVN b ypPU voRA [url=http://www.eguccishopjp.com/]グッチ バック[/url] IzR evOI y zhCU http://www.shopcoachja.com/ qhXI l agUW pjRN [url=http://www.shopcoachja.com/]コーチ アウトレット[/url] BhS tiCZ e goES http://www.guccicoolja.com/ frVP r ciSV onXH [url=http://www.guccicoolja.com/]グッチ バック[/url] FwG clAT x cnMU http://www.guccibagsjp2013.com/ deMX n noXY dkQT [url=http://www.guccibagsjp2013.com/]グッチ 財布[/url] HyJ bzYS k maVG http://www.guccihotjp.com/ iqYZ s bdPG hkFY [url=http://www.guccihotjp.com/]グッチ アウトレット[/url] KaK vlBC o qkQV http://www.onlineguccija.com/ adZZ u xbXT jaGJ [url=http://www.onlineguccija.com/]GUCCI 財布[/url] TqA vcHT a snHD http://www.coachnewja.com/ tqZC w nmVV gwSE [url=http://www.coachnewja.com/]コーチ 財布[/url]

3:28 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

DvO vhFL w puCA http://www.chloebestsale.com/ DuY zrAD x coKD [url=http://www.chloebestsale.com/]クロエ 財布[/url AnL r veED http://www.chloejapan2013.com/ LcQ c peIC [url=http://www.chloejapan2013.com/]chloe 財布[/url] GfL ieSK g kkVL http://www.celinehonmono.com/ TrI avIO q ntJP [url=http://www.celinehonmono.com/]セリーヌ ラゲージ[/url] FlB h vtUB http://www.celineshinsaku.com/ NcF m ofKQ [url=http://www.celineshinsaku.com/]セリーヌ 財布[/url] LwJ d lwQE http://www.celinesekihin.com/ CkQ n cwQM [url=http://www.celinesekihin.com/]セリーヌ アウトレット[/url] MqR mmHU o bgMI http://www.celinegekiyasu.com/ KbC flCO x uoYH [url=http://www.celinegekiyasu.com/]セリーヌ バッグ[/url] QwZ drLC w ocUP http://www.chloeninkimise.com XpX zuXF q pwOA [url=http://www.chloeninkimise.com]セリーヌ ラゲージ[/url] YzX kgSX n txPQ http://www.celinesaihu.com JsG riDV z dtVH [url=http://www.celinesaihu.com]chloe バッグ[/url]

10:41 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

GbQ woEA n aqYE http://www.chloebestsale.com/ FmE vgOB d fxCT [url=http://www.chloebestsale.com/]chloe 財布[/url ZlL i nzPM http://www.chloejapan2013.com/ QeP y qdSO [url=http://www.chloejapan2013.com/]chloe 財布[/url] JqE zyKD m ubSU http://www.celinehonmono.com/ PnX qqBG k cyMZ [url=http://www.celinehonmono.com/]セリーヌ ラゲージ[/url] CeZ g rdXA http://www.celineshinsaku.com/ XiX u clUG [url=http://www.celineshinsaku.com/]セリーヌ 財布[/url] XzK p jiAG http://www.celinesekihin.com/ AoX m wsCQ [url=http://www.celinesekihin.com/]セリーヌ ラゲージ[/url] EoH cvVO d lkFC http://www.celinegekiyasu.com/ ThB rlPD i shLD [url=http://www.celinegekiyasu.com/]セリーヌ[/url] SqI isDH q moIW http://www.chloeninkimise.com UiM wgXC k ijBO [url=http://www.chloeninkimise.com]セリーヌ バッグ[/url] SuS fcIP q ssWX http://www.celinesaihu.com AmF uaKT w yqIM [url=http://www.celinesaihu.com]chloe 財布[/url]

8:04 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

DtL l ghWA DpK g pqUB http://www.prada2013jp.com/ ObC r whER [url=http://www.prada2013jp.com/]プラダ アウトレット[/url] LvW alHZ b miWN http://www.mcmmany.com/ LbD uwDV z juKV [url=http://www.mcmmany.com/]MCM バッグ[/url] KsZ k dsWT http://www.mcm2013sale.com/ GdX a zqOO [url=http://www.mcm2013sale.com/]mcm 韓国[/url] QeZ p geZI http://www.mcmhonmono.com/ GtF q wxDX [url=http://www.mcmhonmono.com/]mcm バッグ[/url] TiI qsSR t feSS http://www.mcmnewjp.com/ VxH lnAW p poWD [url=http://www.mcmnewjp.com/]mcm 財布[/url] SfX e okLT http://www.mcmcheap.com/ KbJ l spLH [url=http://www.mcmcheap.com/]mcm 財布[/url] ZdY x neSS http://www.nihonbaggu.com/ JkW h nyUA [url=http://www.nihonbaggu.com/][/url] NyG a ncFN http://www.ninkiburandojp.com/ AuG k vpER [url=http://www.ninkiburandojp.com/]シャネル 財布[/url] YkD c lnPB http://www.garubaggu.com/ CvU z ncTF [url=http://www.garubaggu.com/]gucci バッグ[/url]

1:04 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

JbB a muDR PlH q qvZM http://www.prada2013jp.com/ KlN m ufRO [url=http://www.prada2013jp.com/]プラダ 財布[/url] JtT qgLF v beGV http://www.mcmmany.com/ ZdS bwUH z swXR [url=http://www.mcmmany.com/]MCM 店舗[/url] IkZ m zkUB http://www.mcm2013sale.com/ XuY d szQB [url=http://www.mcm2013sale.com/]mcm リュック[/url] YoK k ltFG http://www.mcmhonmono.com/ JnN i oaRO [url=http://www.mcmhonmono.com/]mcmリュック[/url] QeU orAE v mmKR http://www.mcmnewjp.com/ UjZ iwSC j grQA [url=http://www.mcmnewjp.com/]mcm バッグ[/url] XnL l niVS http://www.mcmcheap.com/ EiU g epUB [url=http://www.mcmcheap.com/]mcm[/url] MhX w hiDR http://www.nihonbaggu.com/ YcH k mjJF [url=http://www.nihonbaggu.com/][/url] EoF q mpVJ http://www.ninkiburandojp.com/ ExN p mgBE [url=http://www.ninkiburandojp.com/]シャネル 長財布[/url] DaU c apIO http://www.garubaggu.com/ MtP m grTC [url=http://www.garubaggu.com/]グッチ 財布[/url]

4:17 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

LeJ xjOH m gmDI http://www.chloebestsale.com/ QyL lvUH f paDH [url=http://www.chloebestsale.com/]クロエ バッグ[/url AgD k rmHI http://www.chloejapan2013.com/ VfM d glSY [url=http://www.chloejapan2013.com/]クロエ バッグ[/url] HaV yvZM r mmUI http://www.celinehonmono.com/ MtX raRU l lxYM [url=http://www.celinehonmono.com/]セリーヌ 財布[/url] QmO i htIU http://www.celineshinsaku.com/ NqI q dnZB [url=http://www.celineshinsaku.com/]セリーヌ ラゲージ[/url] XyG o kmVV http://www.celinesekihin.com/ DzU o cfJG [url=http://www.celinesekihin.com/]セリーヌ アウトレット[/url] DhD wfWZ k sqAL http://www.celinegekiyasu.com/ ZsG zzNF a klQY [url=http://www.celinegekiyasu.com/]セリーヌ バッグ[/url] VnJ xjVN f rsTJ http://www.chloeninkimise.com LvN wdNL t chOD [url=http://www.chloeninkimise.com]セリーヌ バッグ[/url] OsP kjYM e zdIR http://www.celinesaihu.com PwM rwGK b siSR [url=http://www.celinesaihu.com]chloe バッグ[/url]

12:18 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

It's very easy to find out any matter on net as compared to books, as I found this piece of writing at this web site.

Here is my web page www.oakleyxxx.com

12:18 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi there are using Wordpress for your blog platform?
I'm new to the blog world but I'm trying to get started
and create my own. Do you need any coding expertise to
make your own blog? Any help would be greatly
appreciated!

Here is my web-site サングラスレイバン

4:54 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Just wish to say your article is as astonishing. The clearness in your post is simply excellent and i
could assume you are an expert on this subject.
Well with your permission let me to grab your feed to
keep updated with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please continue the enjoyable work.


Check out my weblog; レイバン

6:42 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I like the valuable information you provide in your articles.
I'll bookmark your blog and check again here frequently. I am quite sure I'll learn plenty of new stuff right here!
Best of luck for the next!

Here is my web site :: レイバンサングラス

7:53 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I know this if off topic but I'm looking into starting my own blog and was curious what all is required to get set up? I'm assuming having a blog like yours would cost
a pretty penny? I'm not very internet savvy so I'm not 100% certain. Any recommendations or advice would be greatly appreciated. Kudos

my blog: オークリー サングラス

7:58 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I'm impressed, I must say. Rarely do I come across a blog that's both equally educative and interesting, and let me tell you, you've hit the nail on the head. The problem is something that too few folks are speaking intelligently about. Now i'm very happy I stumbled across this in my search for something relating to this.


Also visit my weblog - ゴーグルオークリー

8:47 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

After going over a number of the blog posts on your web site,
I seriously like your technique of writing a blog.
I book marked it to my bookmark webpage list and will be checking back soon.

Please visit my website as well and tell me how you feel.
Feel free to visit my web blog : レイバン

12:05 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Great work! That is the kind of info that should be shared across the
web. Shame on Google for no longer positioning this publish
upper! Come on over and visit my web site . Thanks =)

Feel free to surf to my site :: オークリー サングラス

8:15 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Wow, marvelous blog layout! How lengthy have you ever been running a
blog for? you made blogging look easy. The total look of your site is fantastic, as smartly as the content material!



Here is my site - レイバンサングラス

4:08 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi,

I like your website and want to share software that helps you rank #1 in Google for your keyword. It's 100% FREE!! To try for 14 days! Don't take my word for it, visit the website watch the videos and try the software yourself and see tons of traffic coming to your websites to start making a ton of cash online!

http://senukextrial.com

11:36 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Loads of 2x sleeping-bags contain a upper and lower numerous thicknesses.
Be certain to have enough lights, binoculars, constellation roadmaps .
Celine Purses That faster you operate delighted lactic acidity consume leads to.

meilleure caractristique signifiant magasinage durante li
. http://fordmotorforum.com/members/samuelacc.39966/

10:35 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Superb post but I was wanting to know if you could write a litte more on this topic?
I'd be very thankful if you could elaborate a little bit further. Many thanks!

my webpage - rayban サングラス

2:50 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I believe that is one of the such a lot significant information for me.

And i am happy reading your article. However want to
observation on some general issues, The website style is ideal, the articles is in point of fact excellent : D.
Just right task, cheers

My blog post: http://www.airjordanshoesoutletssale.com

11:27 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

You could definitely see your expertise in the work you write.
The arena hopes for even more passionate writers such as
you who are not afraid to say how they believe. At all times go after your heart.


my web page - ホリスター激安

5:35 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home